Popular mystery movies on MovieBay.

The Thing
1982
8.1

The Sixth Sense
1999
8.0

Hereditary
2018
7.3

Scream
1996
7.4

Midsommar
2019
7.1

Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery
2025
7.2

The Hateful Eight
2015
7.8

Oblivion
2013
6.7

Zodiac
2007
7.5

Anatomy of a Fall
2023
7.5

I Want Your Sex
2026
5.9

Mulholland Drive
2001
7.8

Mercy
2026
7.1

Decision to Leave
2022
7.3

Saw
2004
7.4

Rear Window
1954
8.3

Monster
2023
7.9

The Bourne Identity
2002
7.5

Donnie Darko
2001
7.8

The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It
2021
7.3